No tariffs. Ever. We ship locally from the US, Canada, the UK, or the EU + Free shipping over $80 / 70€ / £60 (equivalent in all other currencies).
Search our site
A detail from a Monet painting, depicting a woman holding a parasol staring at the viewer.

Ugly, Yet So Beautiful: Aesthetics and the Christmas Sweater

Written by: C.M. Black

|

Published on

|

Time to read 7 min

Questions Answered in This Blog Post

What determines if something is beautiful or ugly?

Who determines the aesthetics of art and other objects?

Can the beauty of an artwork exist outside of us?

The meme to start with:

Meme: crying Plato demands objective standards for art, while a calm Kant is too busy having a subjective aesthetic experience.

Every year, the tastemakers of the corporate world decide what we should like to do for Christmas. This has been the case for a long time, if we’re honest, but the past decade or so has brought out the arbiters of taste who dictate what we should like in terms of decorating our houses, hosting parties with friends and family, and the general vibe in which we celebrate.


Take this year, for instance. In browsing the hobby store Michaels, which has also recently gained a reputation for selling interesting seasonal decor, your writer discovered something that is apparently “trending” this year: the word kitschmas. What does this word, which I’d never encountered before in my life, mean in terms of how things look?


Someone, somewhere, the tastemaker of current culture, decided that this year we should all be decorating our homes and offices in tacky decor, reimaginings of brightly colored “vintage” ornaments, rosy cheeked Santas, and gaudy gingerbread houses. It’s a lot, but it’s what you’re supposed to like, this year.


Of course, the idea of kitschmas, from the German word kitsch, literally “garbage,” is a vibe you should be familiar with in Christmas culture with the advent of the ugly Christmas sweater a long time ago. So long ago…


But commercialism aside, what do we mean when we say something is ugly? What do we mean when we say it is beautiful? And how can a tinsel-coated trainwreck of a Christmas tree (or Christmas sweater, for that matter) be both hideous and beautiful? Let’s talk about a branch of philosophy called aesthetics.



What Is Beauty?: Aesthetics as a Study


The question “What is beauty?” is one that has plagued Western philosophy in particular since the beginning. Look back to Socrates and you can see many instances where the bearded philosopher scurries around asking about how we define beauty, and what it entails. For Plato, who pens Socrates’s exploits in the dialogues, beauty is not only important to understand, but is also a moral good. Something we can talk about in more detail another time.


However, as humans, we like to make things. You can look at everything from the Lascaux cave paintings to Andy Warhol’s pop art to see that we like to make things that have a value outside of a practical value, things we can call pretty and enjoy for the sake of pretty.


The desire to create is one thing that philosophers such as Aristotle and Karl Marx discuss in detail in their works, the difference, for instance, between craft and art, and how the one is practical and the other for higher purposes, according to Aristotle. And for Marx, creation is central to being human, and a great reason why labor becomes alienated when the creator is separated from the creation.


But what about beauty in and of itself? When you have the opportunity to look at a painting in a museum, for instance, what is the experience of looking at it, and why did we decide to keep this blurry Monet for several centuries, accepting the weirdly painted water lilies as a form of beauty that transcends time and passing fads?


Luckily, we have a whole branch of philosophy that examines art and beauty in depth. Aesthetics is a branch of philosophical study that examines what is beautiful, what is appealing, and what can arouse all sorts of emotions in us in terms of art.



Defining Aesthetics: Classy vs. Kitsch


Occasionally, you might hear a more pretentious friend say, “That is just aesthetic!” Or, for your writer, a mostly functioning goth, I often walk about in the world and encounter a (usually younger) person say, “I love your aesthetic!” So what is an aesthetic? And what is aesthetic? What does this mean in philosophy?


In the study of aesthetics, we examine what makes something beautiful, or appealing to taste. In other words, when you see that Monet, even though it can look pretty confusing up front, why do most of us back away and nod to ourselves, acknowledging it looks pretty good? Part of the purpose of an encounter with art is to experience something. To feel something.


However, what defines beauty is incredibly subjective. For instance, you can look at paintings from the Middle Ages to the 19th century and see that the idea of, in particular, female beauty, changes a lot. And, if you’re a nerd like me, you see that even within the nearly thousand year span of the Middle Ages itself, there are lots of changes in the way things look. Literally look at something from 800 CE then something from 1400 CE. It’s nuts.


And of course you have people writing about this. Naturally, Nietzsche (centuries later) writes in quite a few of his books, about what it means for something to be beautiful, and how this is often just a value judgment. Unfortunately, many people have attributed to Nietzsche a quote about a cockroach and a butterfly, value judgments, blah blah. (Please don’t spread that quote.)


But who determines what is beautiful and what is ugly? What is classy and what is kitsch? The answer is a little more (and a little less) complicated than you’d think. 


While famous art critics like the Victorian John Ruskin wrote volumes upon volumes about what art should look like, and associated artists, like the Pre-Raphaelite Brotherhood created manifestos in which they proclaimed they wanted to return to a time when things looked a lot better (according to them), around the time of Italian Renaissance painter Raphael.


Or, if we go back to Claude Monet, who painted during the same century as the Pre-Raphaelites, but a little later (and in France), we can see how his weird and different paintings, with their crazy brushstrokes and oddly abstract landscapes were not immediately well-received by art critics at the time. Now, however, Monet paintings fill celebrated walls of museums.


We keep Monet and even the Pre-Raphaelites, nodding to ourselves that they have an intrinsic value, related to the artistic beauty of the works and the feelings they inspire in us, the viewer. But if these paintings are cool, do we assign the same values to other paintings of the time?


We only see the great masterworks of the 19th century today, but there were a heck of a lot of people painting back then, whether recreationally or trying to create a career of it (and failing). For every cool daguerreotype of someone like Edgar Allan Poe, I can assure you there are probably 100 pornographic images the Victorians captured with their newfound cameras.


So, after having gone off into Victorian art hell, let’s just say this: aesthetics are highly subjective. We can say that there is an enduring beauty to Claude Monet’s paintings, to such an extent that we devote museums to them, and would pay a lot of money to own one, but this value is not intrinsic to the painting itself. 

Monet's Woman with a Parsol, featuring a woman looking at the viewer, in the foreground, a child to the left.

Woman with a Parasol; Madame Monet and Her Son (1875) by Claude Monet, courtesy of Wiki Commons and Google Art Project



The Hype of Aesthetics: Put on That Sweater


And while it may be kind of disappointing to learn that the paintings and other artworks that your art history professor told you were the thing of the time period they came out of are not in and of themselves beautiful or ugly, if you think about it, it’s kind of liberating. Because at the end of the day, a work of art doesn’t exist in a void. You can’t cast a value judgment on something if you haven’t seen it. It’s the reason why we have reactions of awe or revulsion at things we see and evaluate and judge on their aesthetic value.


You couldn’t determine how beautiful something is without a viewer to do that. At the end of the day, even Monet’s paintings are just a bunch of paint slapped onto a canvas (albeit with skill). If we evaluated paintings in that way, well, every painting would have equal aesthetic value.


This is why you can look at a decor collection of cheap and gaudy objects and roll your eyes, because, while your best friend might think the kitsch of an ugly Christmas sweater, for instance, is the best thing ever, you can shrug and keep looking for the things that are beautiful to you, and that make you happy. You don’t need me to tell you that, though.

Summary:

Aesthetics is the philosophical study of beauty.

Philosophy has a long tradition of asking about what is beautiful.

To assess something as beautiful or ugly is highly subjective.

Art objects that we revere as beautiful were not always seen that way.

We should determine for ourselves what we find beautiful, rather than letting others determine this for us.

A portrait of a woman in black wearing cat-eye style glasses.

C.M. Black

C.M. Black holds a B.A. in Philosophy from Wesleyan College and an M.A. in Technical and Professional Writing from Middle Georgia State University. A lifelong goth, she resides in Atlanta, Georgia, where she works as a professional writer. You can view more of her work on Substack, or follow her on Bluesky and Facebook.

Related Products:

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR MEMESLETTER


You liked this blog post and don't want to miss any new articles? Receive a weekly update with the best philosophy memes on the internet for free and directly by email. On top of that, you will receive a 10% discount voucher for your first order.

Related articles